Copycat Marie Callender's Chicken Pot Pie Recipe - Recipes.net (2024)

Despite being famous for their endless array of dessert pies, Marie Callender has a hearty pie up her sleeve. No, it’s not her German Chocolate Pie, although we do have a recipe for that too. Serve a warm slice of our Copycat Marie Callender’ Chicken Pot recipe for a perfect deep-dish meal that makes less of a mess and more food for everyone to enjoy! With each bite of this homemade chicken pot pie, you’ll be able to taste their famous tender chicken chunks, savory seasonings, and vegetables in a beautiful flaky crust. Prepare to be blown away by a creamy filling packed with all kinds of textures and flavors that will leave you wanting more.

How to Make Chicken Pot Pie Crust

Before we hop into this easy pot pie recipe, first we need to know how to prepare the crust. The flaky texture of the crust is a great combination with the creamy filling. With each slice, you’re greeted with a crisp sound of the exterior and its warm, mouth-watering filling. Using a pre-made crust will also give you an amazing flaky crust for your chicken pot pie plus a hassle-free prep. The bottom of the pot pie crust should have a fluted edge for the sole reason of stability. Apart from holding the filling, this prevents it from seeping between the edges that result in a soggy pie.

When you flute the edge, use your thumb to push the crust in the direction where your index finger and other thumb are holding the crust in place. Do this around the pie and there you have a fluted edge. Aside from fluting the bottom, you also have to slit the top of the chicken pot pie crust. This creates a vent for the steam to escape as your pot pie is baking. If you wish to deviate from the pie crust, easily turn this into a bisquick chicken pot pie recipe by mixing a cup of bisquick mix, one egg, and half a cup of milk to make a golden-brown crust.

Try another house specialty with our Copycat Marie Callender’s Southern Pecan Pie recipe. It’s a great way to practice your pie-making skills plus you’d ace that fluted edge. So, let’s head right into making the best chicken pot pie recipe!

How to Make Homemade Chicken Pot Pie

The eyebrow-raising origin of the pot pie recipe dates back to the Romans where they would serve it in banquets with live birds under the crust. From there, the brits switched up the meat to lambs, pork, or deer meat. The Americans adapted to chickens and other available meat, hence our easy chicken pot pie with pie crust.

Nowadays, we simply throw in leftover chicken meat, peas, carrots, and onion for an easy chicken pot pie like in this Chicken Pot Pie Recipe. You can easily make a homemade pot pieusing a saucepan as well. Others also try to switch up the meat in their usual chicken pot pie by following either a beef pot pie recipe or turkey pot pie recipe for a deliciously filling meal.

You can either pour the filling onto the pie crust and bake or serve as it is. You can even make a crustless instant pot chicken pot pie for a last-minute dinner! Learn about great pairing suggestions and more, by checking out our CAQ section down below. Our recipe offers a quick and easy way to assemble your pie just in time for dinner. We can guarantee it’s the best chicken pot pie recipe especially since Marie Callender has yet to disappoint.

Want to share your thoughts on this Copycat Marie Callender's Chicken Pot Pie Recipe? Head over to the Recipe Sharing section of our forum and join the discussion!

What do I serve with chicken pot pie?

Green veggies like salad, stir-fried green beans, or asparagus make a delicious side. You can also try bread rolls and even potatoes. Try our Vinegar-Marinated Green Beans recipe to pair with your chicken pot pie!

How do I store and reheat chicken pot pie?

Reheating depends on how you stored your chicken pot pie. You can make it ahead and store the filling in an airtight container. Place it in the freezer and allow it to thaw in the fridge the night before you plan to bake it. Reheat the filling in a saucepan for 5 to 6 minutes and assemble the pot pie as instructed. If you’re going to be reheating leftovers, cover the crust with aluminum foil and preheat your oven to 300 degrees F. Let it bake for 30 minutes, occasionally checking every 10 minutes. This is to ensure that your crust will not burn and your pie doesn’t get mushy.